11 rentals in Crestline

Rental Listings in Crestline, OH

$2,600

FOR RENT

210 Wylerhorn Drive, Crestline, CA 92325

4 beds · 2 baths · 1,642 sqft

$1,850

FOR RENT

1021 Coulter Pine, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,344 sqft

$2,300

FOR RENT

979 Venus Way, Crestline, CA 92325

2 beds · 2 baths · 800 sqft

$1,875

FOR RENT

22927 Crest Forest, Crestline, CA 92325

2 beds · 1 baths · 704 sqft

$2,250

FOR RENT

23747 Bowl, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,200 sqft

$1,175

FOR RENT

23335 Crestline Road, Crestline, CA 92352

0 beds · 1 baths · 300 sqft

$3,750

FOR RENT

24649 Valle Drive, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,332 sqft

$3,800

FOR RENT

723 Bergschrund, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 3 baths · 1,958 sqft

$2,300

FOR RENT

23949 Scenic, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,552 sqft

$2,150

FOR RENT

725 Tyrol Drive, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 950 sqft

$3,150

FOR RENT

24656 Bernard, Crestline, CA 92325

4 beds · 3 baths · 2,344 sqft

About Crestline, OH Real Estate

Crestline is a mountain community near Lake Gregory. Features affordable mountain living, outdoor recreation, and small-town atmosphere.

Today, Crestline has 11 homes for rent at a median rent of $2,300/mo, typically leasing in about 56 days.

Top Rated Schools in Crestline

3Valley of Enchantment Elementaryelementary

Why Live in Crestline?

Lake Gregory
Affordable mountain
Small-town feel
Outdoor recreation

Popular Neighborhoods in Crestline

Crestline Village Cedar Pines Park Skyforest Meadow Bay Lake Gregory

Crestline Rental Pulse

Median Rent

$2,400/mo

↑ 37.1% over the past year

$3.3K$2.6K$2K$1.4K

Sep 25

Dec 25

Mar 26

Jun 26

Months of Rental Inventory

Estimated time to lease all rentals at the current leasing pace

0.8 months of supply

Landlord's Market

With only 11 active rentals, supply is tight.

Landlord's (<3 mo)

Balanced (3–6 mo)

Renter's (6+ mo)

0.8

0369+

What this means for renters

Rental inventory is tight relative to how many homes get leased each month—fewer options, and well-priced units draw competition. Rentals typically lease in ~56 days.

● Landlord's: high demand● Balanced: steady pace● Renter's: more leverage

Rental Velocity

How fast rentals are leasing

Slower Pace

Rentals are taking longer to lease—renters have more time to compare options and negotiate. Leasing 84% faster than 6 months ago.

● <30d: Landlords● 30–45d: Balanced● 45d+: Renters

Rental Inventory Distribution

Balanced Market

Rentals are leasing at a healthy pace—more listings move within 30 days than sit longer on the market.

New

Active

Aging

Stale

Most rentals are leasing within a month, but a meaningful share is starting to linger longer.

Under 30 days → competitive—act quicklyOver 60 days → potential negotiation opportunities

Housing Tenure in Crestline

Homeownership is significantly higher than average—this is a homeowner-dominated market with more long-term residents.

HomeownersRenters

74%

Homeowners

26%

Renters

Homeownership is 18.5% higher than the California average (55.5%)

Higher ownership rates often reflect more stable neighborhoods and longer-term residents.

4,047 households (2023)

Median Rent by Bedroom

Rent increases with bedroom count, with moderate premiums for additional space.

2 Bed

$2,088

3 Bed

$2,683

4 Bed

$2,875

Each additional bedroom adds about $393.5/mo to rent on average, with larger units commanding higher premiums.

Largest increase: 2 → 3 bedrooms (+$595/mo)

Rent Reductions

High Activity

5 listings have reduced their rent

45% of active listings

Average reduction: 6.5% (~$150/mo)

A significant share of landlords are reducing rents—this suggests a softening rental market where renters have strong negotiating leverage.

Have questions about Crestline?

Connect with a local specialist

Loading Map...

11 rentals in Crestline

Rental Listings in Crestline, OH

$2,600

FOR RENT

210 Wylerhorn Drive, Crestline, CA 92325

4 beds · 2 baths · 1,642 sqft

$1,850

FOR RENT

1021 Coulter Pine, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,344 sqft

$2,300

FOR RENT

979 Venus Way, Crestline, CA 92325

2 beds · 2 baths · 800 sqft

$1,875

FOR RENT

22927 Crest Forest, Crestline, CA 92325

2 beds · 1 baths · 704 sqft

$2,250

FOR RENT

23747 Bowl, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,200 sqft

$1,175

FOR RENT

23335 Crestline Road, Crestline, CA 92352

0 beds · 1 baths · 300 sqft

$3,750

FOR RENT

24649 Valle Drive, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,332 sqft

$3,800

FOR RENT

723 Bergschrund, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 3 baths · 1,958 sqft

$2,300

FOR RENT

23949 Scenic, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,552 sqft

$2,150

FOR RENT

725 Tyrol Drive, Crestline, CA 92325

3 beds · 2 baths · 950 sqft

$3,150

FOR RENT

24656 Bernard, Crestline, CA 92325

4 beds · 3 baths · 2,344 sqft

About Crestline, OH Real Estate

Crestline is a mountain community near Lake Gregory. Features affordable mountain living, outdoor recreation, and small-town atmosphere.

Today, Crestline has 11 homes for rent at a median rent of $2,300/mo, typically leasing in about 56 days.

Top Rated Schools in Crestline

3Valley of Enchantment Elementaryelementary

Why Live in Crestline?

Lake Gregory
Affordable mountain
Small-town feel
Outdoor recreation

Popular Neighborhoods in Crestline

Crestline Village Cedar Pines Park Skyforest Meadow Bay Lake Gregory

Crestline Rental Pulse

Median Rent

$2,400/mo

↑ 37.1% over the past year

$3.3K$2.6K$2K$1.4K

Sep 25

Dec 25

Mar 26

Jun 26

Months of Rental Inventory

Estimated time to lease all rentals at the current leasing pace

0.8 months of supply

Landlord's Market

With only 11 active rentals, supply is tight.

Landlord's (<3 mo)

Balanced (3–6 mo)

Renter's (6+ mo)

0.8

0369+

What this means for renters

Rental inventory is tight relative to how many homes get leased each month—fewer options, and well-priced units draw competition. Rentals typically lease in ~56 days.

● Landlord's: high demand● Balanced: steady pace● Renter's: more leverage

Rental Velocity

How fast rentals are leasing

Slower Pace

Rentals are taking longer to lease—renters have more time to compare options and negotiate. Leasing 84% faster than 6 months ago.

● <30d: Landlords● 30–45d: Balanced● 45d+: Renters

Rental Inventory Distribution

Balanced Market

Rentals are leasing at a healthy pace—more listings move within 30 days than sit longer on the market.

New

Active

Aging

Stale

Most rentals are leasing within a month, but a meaningful share is starting to linger longer.

Under 30 days → competitive—act quicklyOver 60 days → potential negotiation opportunities

Housing Tenure in Crestline

Homeownership is significantly higher than average—this is a homeowner-dominated market with more long-term residents.

HomeownersRenters

74%

Homeowners

26%

Renters

Homeownership is 18.5% higher than the California average (55.5%)

Higher ownership rates often reflect more stable neighborhoods and longer-term residents.

4,047 households (2023)

Median Rent by Bedroom

Rent increases with bedroom count, with moderate premiums for additional space.

2 Bed

$2,088

3 Bed

$2,683

4 Bed

$2,875

Each additional bedroom adds about $393.5/mo to rent on average, with larger units commanding higher premiums.

Largest increase: 2 → 3 bedrooms (+$595/mo)

Rent Reductions

High Activity

5 listings have reduced their rent

45% of active listings

Average reduction: 6.5% (~$150/mo)

A significant share of landlords are reducing rents—this suggests a softening rental market where renters have strong negotiating leverage.

Have questions about Crestline?

Connect with a local specialist

Loading Map...