8 homes in Blue Jay
Homes for Sale in Blue Jay, Lake Arrowhead
Blue Jay Market Snapshot
$399K
Median Price
$389
Avg $/Sq Ft
71
Avg Days on Market
5
New This Week
About Blue Jay, Lake Arrowhead
Blue Jay is a sought-after neighborhood in Lake Arrowhead, OH. Currently, there are 40 homes for sale in this area with a median listing price of $399K. The average price per square foot is $389.
Blue Jay Market Pulse
Median Home Price
$355K
↓ 30.4% over the past yearSales Velocity
How fast homes are selling
Homes are sitting on the market—buyers often have strong leverage to negotiate price, terms, and repairs. Sales have slowed 7% compared to 6 months ago.
Inventory Distribution
Homes are taking longer to sell—a larger share of listings remain on the market beyond 30 days, giving buyers more leverage.
Median Price by Bedroom
Home prices rise significantly with each additional bedroom.
Each additional bedroom adds about $97K in value on average, with larger homes seeing bigger price jumps.
Largest increase: 3 → 4 bedrooms (+$354K)
Nearby Neighborhoods in Lake Arrowhead
Explore More in Lake Arrowhead
Looking for a home in Blue Jay?
Connect with a local specialist